Why do the DWP GEC hate sex workers?

Last month, the publication of motions to be debated at this year’s DWP Group Conference gave all of us an insight into the socially conservative politics of the current group leadership.

However well-meaning some of its supporters may be, Motion A11 seeks to negotiate with the employer to penalise claimants who use OnlyFans and similar platforms as a form of self-employment.

Many people, especially women as the motion rightly points out, have chosen to run OnlyFans accounts in order to earn money. The motion not only passes moral judgement on these women, but states that the union should negotiate with the DWP to stop treating OnlyFans or others as acceptable gainful forms of self-employment under UC (Universal Credit) or any other DWP benefits/programmes.

Currently, if a UC claimant is deemed in gainful self-employment they are exempt from looking for other work. Additionally, newly self-employed claimants may get a start-up period where the minimum income floor for being self-employed is not applied and no conditionality is applied for a year.

Some claimants, but by no stretch of the imagination an endemic proportion, use online platforms to sell adult content. That is their work; their business.

The DWP Group Executive want to strip those claimants of these rights. Meaning that adult content creators will not be able to use that work as contributing to gainful self-employment and will be subject to conditionality for their benefits. Perversely, they do this under the sadistic pretence that in order to protect these women, the solution is to punish them.

OnlyFans is legal, and therefore up to now, the DWP have had no choice but to allow it to be used as a form of self-employment, as they do with UberEats, Deliveroo etc. Like all those other platforms it is a multi-million pound company which exploits the labour of those who use it. This, we would argue would be a better angle: to attack the platform rather than penalise the users.

One of the arguments used to backup this position is that all claimants are ‘at risk of being forced by the DWP to take up OnlyFans as self-employment’. This is not true, but serves to help whip-up moralistic panic. Of course, the Department doesn’t and hasn’t forced any specific type of self-employment on anyone. And contrary to online claims, there is no training or departmental guidance which encourages work coaches to do this.

The motion also claims that ‘DWP must not give pimps the opportunity to financially abuse women or coerce them into prostitution’. We agree, but there is a difference between OnlyFans claimants using their earnings as gainful self-employment and coercive sexual exploitation. One is legal and a choice, the other is illegal and not.

For the sake of our claimants, we hope the motion falls, but if not, OnlyFans will still exist and will be used by some people regardless of whether the GEC is successful in convincing the employer of its moralistic crusade.

A Prohibitionist Approach that Increases Harm

Just like prostitution, if you delegitimise and stigmatise those who work in the sex industry, you push the workers closer to the pimps and further into exploitation, not the opposite.

Delegates to the DWP Group Conference will rightly care for the welfare of claimants engaged in OnlyFans. It is incredibly counterproductive to argue that the state should penalise them. Instead, the union should focus on practical ways it can support them.

OnlyFans claimants would have a rightful grievance against the DWP for refusing access to public funds on the same basis as other self-employed claimants and against the union for arguing for it. PCS Independent Left would be supportive of them.

As trade unionists we should understand that the best way to support those in exploitative workplaces and industries is to organise the workers to fight for better conditions.

We should listen to sex workers who have already organised. Decriminalisation and harm reduction approaches are widely supported by sex worker-led organisations. Criminalisation and exclusion push work underground, making people less safe and less able to seek support. Refusing to recognise lawful income does not protect claimants; it penalises disclosure, increases fear of sanctions, and weakens proper safeguarding.

Recognising income is not the same as promoting an activity. Welfare systems assess income, not moral worth. Giving the DWP power to decide which lawful work “counts” risks moral policing and could be used against many other precarious, marginalised workers. It strengthens the despised hostile environment for claimants that successive governments have built. We should dismantle it completely, and abolish the regime of sanctions and conditionality.

A policy that removes official recognition of sex-related income would disproportionately affect women, increasing poverty, insecurity, and dependency; the very conditions that enable exploitation. Safety comes from rights, visibility, adequate benefits, and voluntary support, not forced exclusion.

We urge delegates to vote against Motion A11.

Conference should oppose this and instead support a claimant-led approach of decriminalisation; tackling coercion, improving necessary safeguarding, and addressing poverty without increasing stigma or state control over people’s lives.

Join PCS 4 DECRIM

PCS4DECRIM is a grassroots group of PCS lay reps who are campaigning for PCS to adopt a policy of the full decriminalisation of sex work in the UK.
To get involved with the campaigning in PCS, email pcs4decrim@gmail.com and you can be added to their mailing list.